16 Comments
User's avatar
Martha Ture's avatar

I am reading Hannah Arendt’s Eichmann in Jerusalem – A Report on the Banality of Evil.

She attends Eichmann's trial, takes notes, deeply seeks to understand how Eichmann and his cohort could have done what they did.

And she learns that Eichmann was stupid, that he was a lifelong joiner, that he could not conceive of his life without having orders to follow, a group to which to belong. In short, he was an ordinary person, not an evil monster. He was the guy in the area under the bell curve. She wrote her conclusions – that ordinary people can commit evil without being malicious or monstrous, but rather through thoughtlessness, bureaucratic compliance, a failure to think for themselves, a need to belong, to advance in their careers, to please the strong man. Eichmann at his trial said he was “just following orders.” So long as there are no outside voices questioning his thinking, asking why he isn’t following the Ten Commandments, the Golden Rule, he can stay his course.

I thought of the GOP, of course. But I was smacked in the face by Eichmann’s testimony that he was living according to Kant’s categorical imperative.

Say what?

To the bookshelf, back to Kant.

Arendt writes that Eichmann had misunderstood Kant, that he had substituted Hitler for the internal moral authority. At his trial he testified that he was just following orders.

Thus is the GOP revealed. They are just following orders. They do not contain multitudes. They contain Trump.

Expand full comment
Denise's avatar

This is true but the comparison between Eichmann and Trump doesn’t quite work. This is because Trump’s psychological profile puts him into a rare class where he is far from ordinary. Being a malignant narcissist with a sociopathy that means he has no conscience, no empathy, no self-awareness and definitely no self control, he acts without shame or impunity. He only considers other people in terms of their value or use to him. He sought and obtained the presidency because he saw it as a means of exacting revenge, being immune from his only fear, imprisonment, building up his wealth by plundering the nation and walking the world stage as some kind of hero. The Chosen One!

The depths of his depravity are as yet unfathomed.

Expand full comment
Mary's avatar

Agreed. TFG is capable of living in a vacuum of Self.

No external oxygen required or in fact can be tolerated.

He exists in a bubble that his lifetime of vast wealth has helped maintain for far FAR too long.

Expand full comment
Martha Ture's avatar

As we note, I was referring to Eichmann and to the GOP in Congress. Their common points are the need to be in a group, to please the bully, to be insulated from moral criticism, and to follow orders - in order to release dopamine. I get my kicks on other trips.

Expand full comment
Debbie Blick's avatar

Sharing this for the world to see

Expand full comment
Marjorie's avatar

Great article, spot on. We all know DT is evil, mixed with narcissism, dementia, depravity, greed, sadism, cankles, etc. That's just what he is. I'm far more disgusted with his enablers. They (at some time in the past) knew better, yet they fall in line and bow to his every whim.

Expand full comment
Mary's avatar

Shout out to the bit:

“… the monster noticing a bigger, louder, more radioactive monster lumbering out of the fog and thinking, “Oh hell. That thing’s not housebroken.”

Expand full comment
Merry's avatar
2hEdited

There simply are no words to adequately describe the depravity of douchebag Donny. He’s a whole new breed of human evil. Next level. The Beast on steroids. Jabba the Hutt.

Perhaps he was designed and delivered by off-planet, soulless alien creatures, like musk.

In any event, Trump may be living proof that evil itself evolves, and that Mephistopheles needs to up his game. Like SOON. Think he’s up to the challenge? And what comes after treachery?

(And why is djt so obsessed by Hannibal Lecter?)

https://www.theguardian.com/culture/article/2024/jul/25/donald-trump-hannibal-lecter

Expand full comment
Susie Wilson's avatar

I love these descriptions of evil and ignorant ego evil.

Expand full comment
pete gee's avatar

Further nailed by Martha and by Debbie's intent

Expand full comment
Supermrsc's avatar

Not only do you make a good point, but you made it with some hella good writing. Hats off to you for insight and wordsmithery.

Expand full comment
Suzanne Thompson's avatar

Fantastic writing 👏

Expand full comment
FeatheredBeak's avatar

Epstein may not have been able or willing to leverage Trump, but we are waiting for (ras)Putin to play his fifth ace. You know he’s got a full deck of faces & aces up his sleeve and just bided his time until the stench is ripe enough.

Expand full comment
Yvonne McCarthy's avatar

Trump is visceral, endemic evil, but even that can be swallowed by a black hole of evidence.

Expand full comment
Tamie McDermott's avatar

No truer words ever written

Expand full comment
Chris Kuebler's avatar

"and Trump was un-leverageable"

This is so incredibly apt. In fact - in the email messages that were revealed... Jeffrey Epstein himself remarks about Trump in "post-leverageable" terms. Instead of leveraging Trump - Epstein talked about using Trump as political capital. Not in a way that would actually leverage Trump. But instead in a way to provide gains for his own organization having navigated Trump's known evil tendencies.

Expand full comment