Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Maria Jette's avatar

FANTASTIC essay. I’m a Minnesotan, and neither a farmer nor a rural resident, but occasionally have to head out of the largely progressive metrop of MSP into “Greater Minnesota,” which starts about 1” from the further edge of the first-ring suburbs. I’m also a classical musician by trade, and that makes me an out of touch elitist, so my world is 98% empathetic, literate, thoughtful/tortured progressives— and that means that any time I’ve ventured out there in the last 9 years, I’ve been stunned at the Trump signs in farmers’ fields. Not as many this election, but ANY is shocking to me, given how farmers and rural folk were screwed by 1st-term Trump (and helped by Biden— with broadband in particular).

So many of those ag people are working their butts off for most hours of the day, compared to people like me (or “us,” as I imagine I can dub the readers of this substack) who are reading endless reams of reports and opinion pieces in our kitchens and offices. We’re all ultimately tribal, and their tribe shares Trumpy non-facts, which they haven’t the time or inclination (mostly time) to check out. Ergo, they were still somehow convinced that he gave a flying fuck about them. It’s really, truly tragic— and the left has been gloating far too much in the FAFO mode about the horror those people— the PEOPLE, not the mega-corporations who’ve been buying up family farms at blinding speed for the last 15 years—are experiencing. And they’re astonished by it, because they haven’t been following Trump via Vanity Fair articles in the 80’s, and NYT articles in the 00’s (and before and since!), and all the other reportage which has detailed his crap business dealings, and shocking treatment of workers and purveyors etc etc etc., and NEED to believe him when he says he’s on their side, because the Democrats have done a TERRIBLE job of PR, which could’ve helped them see that Trump didn’t care about them and never would!

In summation: any living American person in 2025 who can use the word “groceries” as if it were an adorable bit of vocab from Dickens (which he’s just learned, and is delighted to be displaying to the world), DOES NOT UNDERSTAND WHERE FOOD COMES FROM, and never will. Ergo, his total evisceration of the US agricultural system is, to him, a fun game of strategy, like Battleship. Winners, losers— all FUN!

Expand full comment
V Lowery's avatar

I love it that you stated that team-building exercises and holiday parties at work are NOT fun. I agree; I always hated forced socializing.

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts